FLOAT
EN FR

The path · 3 Advanced

Repair instead of cropping

The project of the second tutorial is opened again and its crop loosened to the whole field, a third more area. A dust stain is healed with Spot healing, and the comet-shaped stars of the edges are redrawn by the Synthetic stars block, the real stars being painted back at the centre.

Table 1.The tutorial at a glance.
DurationAbout 10 min, of which 10 s of computing
Requirements
  • FLOAT installed
  • The tutorial The full processing: stars apart done: its finished project (about 1.8 GB) is the starting point
  • Disk space: about 2 GB for a copy of that project
Data set Rosette Nebula (NGC 2237) · Sony A7S, 15 s at ISO 4000 · 130/900 Newtonian · 436 lights (1.8 h), 48 darks, 62 flats, the authors of FLOAT; size 6.9 GB. The frames will be offered for download; the link will be given here
The whole field of the Rosette Nebula, 4,200 × 2,780 px: 33 % more area than the second tutorial, and round stars to the edges. The sky reads 34, 34 and 33 in red, green and blue, and it differs by 3.7 levels from corner to corner, against 6 before.
The result. The whole field of the Rosette Nebula, 4,200 × 2,780 px: 33 % more area than the second tutorial, and round stars to the edges. The sky reads 34, 34 and 33 in red, green and blue, and it differs by 3.7 levels from corner to corner, against 6 before.

1Open the project

On the Home screen click Open project… and choose the finished project of the second tutorial, or a copy of its folder. The project opens up to date: nothing is to be computed.

Expected result. The status bar reads all up to date, and the Run button is greyed.

Open the project
Figure 1.Open the project.

2Diagnosis in Post

Click Post. The picture is the result of the second tutorial: clean and quiet, but tightly cropped, because the first tutorial cut two defects away instead of repairing them. Before any gesture, click Crop: the whole field appears around the frame and the two defects come back. Leave with Cancel. Right, and to leave alone: the sky level and neutrality, the denoised gas and the star settings of the second tutorial.

Expected result. The sky is dark and neutral: on the exported picture it reads 34, 34 and 33 in red, green and blue on a 0 to 255 scale, neutral within one level. The sky is read before it is corrected, and here no gesture is needed.

Diagnosis in Post
Figure 2.Diagnosis in Post.
The diagnosis before touching Post.
What is wrongHow it is readWhat corrects it
The field is tight.The picture is about 3,500 px wide. With Crop open, the frame shows what the first tutorial gave up around it: a band of sky and stars on every side.Loosen the crop to the whole field. (step 6)
A dark stain at the left edge.With Crop open, zoom to 100 % (Ctrl and the mouse wheel over the picture) at the left edge, outside the frame: a dark patch, with a smaller one beside it.Spot healing on the starless image. (step 7)
Comet-shaped stars along the edges and in the corners.Zoom to 100 % in a corner: the stars are stretched like comets, while those at the centre of the field are round. It is the coma of the telescope.Add the Synthetic stars block, then paint the real stars back at the centre. (step 3)

3Add the Synthetic stars block

Click Graph. In the palette, double-click Synthetic stars: the block takes its place after Stars/background, with the method Image shape, the default.

Why. The stars of the edges and corners are comet-shaped: that is the coma of this telescope, which has no corrector. Image shape measures the shape of the stars at the centre of the field, where it is round, and redraws every detected star with it. The brightest stars are left real.

Expected result. The status bar reads to run: ≤ 1 min.

Add the Synthetic stars block
Figure 3.Add the Synthetic stars block.

4Run the block

Click Run. The Run project window lists every block: all are up to date except Synthetic stars, which alone is computed. It takes about 10 s.

Why. Each block is computed once, and a change only runs again the blocks that follow it: nothing else is recomputed.

Expected result. The window ends with 1 block computed, and the status bar reads all up to date.

Run the block
Figure 4.Run the block.

5The new rows in Post

Close the window and click Post. The Stars group of the layer now holds two rows, Synthetic stars and Real stars. The mask of the Synthetic stars row is white: it starts open, so the synthetic stars replace all the real ones.

Why. Post builds these rows by itself once the block is computed. The mask is what chooses, point by point, between the synthetic stars and the real ones.

Expected result. The thumbnail of the mask of the Synthetic stars row is white.

The new rows in Post
Figure 5.The new rows in Post.

6Loosen the crop

Click Crop. Drag the top left corner of the frame to the corner of the field, then the bottom right corner to the edge, keeping only the black borders of the alignment out: a few pixels on the right, at the top and at the bottom. Click Apply.

Why. The first tutorial cropped because a beginner should not have to repair. At this level the defects are repaired instead, so the field they were hiding is taken back: the ring breathes in a wider field, and the stars around it give the scale.

Expected result. The panel reads about 4,200 × 2,780 px, a third more area (33 %) than the tight crop. The stain and the comet-shaped stars are back.

Loosen the crop
Figure 6.Loosen the crop.

7Heal the stain

Click the Starless image row, then Spot healing. Zoom in on the stain at the left edge, drag Size until the circle covers the whole stain with a margin (here about 140 px) and click on it. Reduce Size to about 90 px for the small stain beside it and click on it too. The source is found automatically, in clean sky nearby.

Why. The stain is the shadow of a dust grain on the sensor: the flats used come from another night, so they do not correct it. On a stack of two nights, the second turned by 178°, the stain is 24 % shallower: a shadow on the sensor is diluted that way, and a dark cloud in the sky would not be. The tool goes on the starless image because there are no stars to copy along with the sky, so the patch is invisible; on the combined image the patch would copy stars and double them.

Expected result. The panel reads 2 spots healed, and the sky is even where the stain was, with no lighter or darker patch where the sky was taken.

The stain at the left edge at 100 %.
Before. The stain at the left edge at 100 %.
The same zone after the two clicks: the sky is even.
After. The same zone after the two clicks: the sky is even.
Heal the stain
Figure 7.Heal the stain.

8Paint the real stars back at the centre

Click the Synthetic stars row, then its mask: the brush appears, set to Subtract (the list also offers Add and Intersect). Drag Size to the right until the brush is as large as it goes, here 1,200 px, and Hardness to 0, then paint one stroke across the centre of the field.

Why. The real stars come back at the centre, where the optics are good; outside it, the round synthetic stars replace the comet-shaped ones. The coma grows from the centre outwards: it is already visible at 1,000 px from the corners, along the whole left edge. Painting the four corners would leave half of the comet-shaped stars in place, whereas painting the one zone where the optics are good is a single gesture and covers all the rest.

Expected result. The thumbnail of the mask shows a dark patch at the centre, and the red tint covers the centre with a soft edge.

Paint the real stars back at the centre
Figure 8.Paint the real stars back at the centre.

9Check at 100 %

Click the top row of the layer and zoom to 100 % (Ctrl and the mouse wheel) in a corner, then at the centre. In the corner the comet-shaped stars are round; at the centre the real stars are unchanged, with their spikes. On the fitted view, nothing shows where the mask fades, and the star density does not jump.

Why. The brush fades out with Hardness at 0, so the real and the synthetic stars meet without a seam.

A corner at 100 % before: the stars are comet-shaped.
Corner before. A corner at 100 % before: the stars are comet-shaped.
The same corner after: the stars are round.
Corner after. The same corner after: the stars are round.
An edge zone before.
Edge before. An edge zone before.
The same edge zone after: the comet-shaped stars are round.
Edge after. The same edge zone after: the comet-shaped stars are round.
The centre of the cluster before.
Centre before. The centre of the cluster before.
The centre after: the real stars are unchanged.
Centre after. The centre after: the real stars are unchanged.
Synthetic stars everywhere: the bright stars of the cluster lose their spikes and look drawn.
Pushed too far. Synthetic stars everywhere: the bright stars of the cluster lose their spikes and look drawn.
Check at 100 %
Figure 9.Check at 100 %.

10Export

Click Export…, choose JPEG in Format and click Export. The file is named after the project, in its export folder.

Export
Figure 10.Export.

11The image is written

The window says how many files were written: the image and its processing history. Close it. Press Ctrl+S to keep the project with its new block, its widened crop, its two healed spots and its mask.

The image is written
Figure 11.The image is written.

Blocks used